Manchester United will struggle to beat Juventus in the race for Randal Kolo Muani
Last season ended, and hearts were broken again. Manchester United finished 15th in the Premier League—a position once unimaginable in the club’s history. Losing the Europa League final to Tottenham and now out of European competition in 2025/26 were the final nails in the coffin in 2024/25. Ruben Amorim took over the reins mid-season, but the situation was so dire that even his efforts could provide little relief.
Manchester United have been on the decline for three years in a row. The hopes that began under Erik ten Hag had completely faded by the time Amorim arrived. The team was losing its identity, especially in attack. Both Rasmus Hojlund and Joshua Zirkzee failed to live up to expectations. That is why the club are looking for a new striker this summer transfer window.
Strong names like Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo have arrived. Young Diogo Leon has also been added to the squad, but it is clear that the management is still thinking of bringing in a main number nine. Many names are being discussed, but one name that keeps coming up is Randal Kolo Muani.
Can Kolo Muani change the picture?
Some reports have claimed that Manchester United are interested in PSG-linked Kolo Muani. However, Manchester Evening News has reported that Juventus are also in the race to sign him. The Frenchman’s first season in France for PSG was not that strong. Juventus want to sign him on loan, but United may be ready for a direct transfer.
The 26-year-old’s speciality is his versatility. He can play both on the wing and in the centre. The Frenchman has good speed, and he also contributes to the pressing game, but his lack of consistency has been his biggest weakness. He scored eight goals in 16 games for Juventus in the Serie A last season, but looked ineffective in between.
Is Muani the right bet?
We are not convinced about signing Kolo Muani. If options like Benjamin Sesko and Ollie Watkins are available, we think they have more value. Sesko is young, his physical profile and instinctive finishing make him a long-term project. He may cost £78m, but that seems like a better investment given his potential and quality.
Watkins, on the other hand, has proven himself in the Premier League – 75 goals in 174 games is no joke. Yes, his age reduces his resale value, but he can bring immediate impact. Kolo Muani was sidelined by PSG, he was decent at Juventus, but his output has been low for the £39m price tag.
If the club miss out on Sesko and Watkins, United will have to make a better offer than Juventus for Kolo Muani—perhaps a permanent deal or a higher fee. The absence of Champions League is a deterrent, but guaranteed minutes and a plan to attack could perhaps convince them. United still have a way to go. However, the question is: will we gamble on an inconsistent striker again, or will we make a more informed decision this time?